City Council member Adam Hornung wants to
save two and a half police officer positions that would otherwise be cut by Mayor Beutler's
proposed budget. That 2.5 officer equivalent would come from no longer having LPD write reports
for non-injury accidents. Officers would still respond when necessary, but they wouldn't write the full reports that insurance companies use when determining fault, setting payout amounts, and deciding on rate increases.
So far I haven't seen Hornung describe where he would get the money to pay for the officers. You can safely bet that he won't want to raise taxes, so that leaves salaries and City programs as the likely source of the money. He'll likely complain about any non-contractually-obligated raises, for example. I'm not sure if the full $150,000 (give or take) could be made up from those raises or not.
I'm not sure what I think about the end of non-injury accident reports. I disagree with Mr. Hornung that the reports represent a mandatory component of public safety in Lincoln. Non-injury reports are merely "nice-to-haves", not "must-haves". Nobody's health is threatened by Beutler's proposal. There are, however, some financial implications to consider. Those involved in non-injury accidents are likely to face higher insurance costs than they otherwise would have seen; in fact, it's possible that
all Lincoln drivers will face slightly higher premiums as a result of this policy change. I don't know that that
will happen, merely that it could.
I was involved in a non-injury accident back in high school. No report was written because it occurred on private property. Boy, a report sure would have been nice. It was the sort of accident in which fault wasn't immediately obvious based on the damage caused. Yet any witness could have told you that my vehicle wasn't even moving in the moments leading up to impact! Fortunately, my insurance company sided with me and I suffered no financial harm. Perhaps I got lucky. Perhaps my Hot Wheels recreation of the accident was just that convincing. All in all, although a report might have made the process a bit smoother, the absence of a report wasn't the end of the world. That's my lone anecdote for you.
Are non-injury accident reports important enough to warrant saving at the cost of other budget items? If so, what should go?