I'm still not certain why, but last night the Lincoln library board
voted to build a $40+ million history museum at the site of Pershing Center. The existing building could be retained, or a new building could be built from scratch for just a few million dollars more.
Why is the library board in the business of building history museums? I'm not sure, to be honest. It seem...
Wait, what? It's not a museum, but an actual, functioning library? People still use libraries? Huh. How 'bout that.
That bit of bad humor was brought to you by the realities of the 21st Century. I've said it for many years now as buzz has grown about building a new main library in Lincoln that the idea doesn't stand a chance unless supporters can figure out how to make it relevant to today's Lincolnites. The present effort doesn't show any sign of making that happen.
In fact, the latest push to build a new main library is entirely without substance. Literally the
only thing the library board has told us is the approximate cost of the building and a specific address. Last night's vote to forward the proposal to Mayor Beutler came without discussion. The lack of supporting material means that we, the public, get to craft the discussion points. Our imaginations get to generate the narrative. The board has given us the power to make whatever we want out of this proposal.
The board has made a huge mistake.
The City of Lincoln has no fat in its budget. Lincolnites are financially exhausted thanks to the stress of national economic woes, years of arena stress, and even the recent news that Lincoln will ask voters to fund a new stormwater bond issue in November. Local real estate values are flat; gas prices are creeping up again; and it's not like trips to the grocery store have gotten cheaper.
And the library board has the gall to ask for $40 million to construct a building that few Lincolnites will ever enter and which will house books that few people will ever read?
Some of you will think I'm being unfair, but don't misunderstand what I'm saying. I'm not saying that a new main library is an inherently bad idea. Rather, I'm pointing out the library board's failure to lead on this issue. Where's the innovation? Where's the excitement? Where's the marketing oomph that helped promote the "Catalyst" and arena projects? Where's the Life is Right tie-in? Look at
Main Library Vision and Concept Study for yourself. Are you inspired by it? No, of course not! It's dry and boring. Even the
electronic presentation [PDF] prepared by Sinclair Hille Architects is bland and unconvincing.
Look, Lincolnites are funny about how they spend their money. Libraries are far from the top of their list of gotta-have-it expenditures. If we're going to build a new main library, somebody is going to have to wow us first. Somebody is going to have to explain why a fresh coat of paint and some new carpet at Bennet Martin isn't good enough. Somebody is going to have to tell us why libraries are still relevant, and how $40 million -- and let's be realistic, it'll cost more than that -- is going to result in something that's relevant community-wide today and well into the foreseeable future.
Somebody needs to inspire us.
So far the library board has given us little more than a rough description of a fancier warehouse for a bunch of relics few people use. They can and they must do better than that.