This Robin is in No Mood to Sing

By: Mr. Wilson on November 28, 2007
City Councilwoman Robin Eschliman sure comes across as cranky in today's Deena Winter column. Or maybe it's just me. In any event, Ms. Eschliman's suggestion that the city's union employees be forced to give to United Way is hardly rational. The best way to encourage charity and goodwill is certainly not to mandate it.


See what your friends and neighbors have to say about this.

November 28, 2007 at 3:39PM

I agree. I know that people where I work (a large company) prefer some freedom in choosing where they donate their charitable dollars and hours, and they don’t always choose United Way. Charity shouldn’t be mandated - that generally causes resentment.

November 28, 2007 at 3:41PM

I agree wholeheartedly, and usually think she comes off as a major, uh, witch. As someone who is familiar with how employers strong-arm their people into giving to the United Way, which makes me mad, I don’t think it should be mandated. With that said, the living wage is, in my opinion, a complete crock, and that shouldn’t be mandated either. She made a very bad analogy in a stupid way on what could have been a valid point. I don’t think communication is her strong suit.

November 28, 2007 at 7:16PM

People who prefer to mandate the way people give money usually have more of it (money) than other people. I don’t know if that’s the case with Eschliman, but it seems like it.

She comes across as naive and dictatorial in the article. She clearly has an ax to grind with her mother’s experience and with the slam against the union. Too bad it gets in the way of her message.

November 28, 2007 at 10:17PM

I hate United Way campaigns. I could find no language about how much of my donation would go to administrative costs (granted, I didn’t look THAT long), and whether United Way takes a cut when you pass the donation to other charities (at UNL, you’re given a choice of other charities to donate to through United Way).

I prefer giving directly to organizations around town.

Dave K
November 29, 2007 at 12:18AM

lol @ ‘witch’

lol @ ‘naive and dictatorial’


I wish you all would react so strongly in other situations when government officials tell us how to spend our money (like when they want to raise taxes).

November 29, 2007 at 1:00AM

Uh, I do react strongly. I don’t like it, and don’t vote for those who I think will raise my taxes. As to Karin, I haven’t seen the numbers lately, but it seems to me that the overhead costs are very high at United Way compared to many of the other charities I would fund. There used to be a web site (probably still is, but I haven’t looked) that showed national and larger charities and the percentage of money that actually flowed through to those who needed the aid versus overhead and administration. Back then, the Make-a-Wish Foundation, which I think is a wonderful group, scored very well, and UW was sucky. I hate the strong-arm tactics that employers use to push up the UW campaign. I’d rather my dollars go elsewhere, but it’s kind of one of those things we feel we “need” to do.

Share your thoughts with the community.

Commenting is no longer permitted on this post.