Wide Open Spaces
By: Mr. Wilson on
April 19, 2011
I'm not crazy about Lincoln's emphasis lately on making arterials as wide as possible. Driving on Pioneers Blvd. around Lucille Dr., for example, I feel like I stumbled across a runway for B-52s. With two lanes each direction, right turn lanes, and a wiiiide center turn lane, there's space galore. We're told that's great for safety, but it's killer on our wallets and ugly as sin, not to mention the fact that it invites drivers to speed like they're on the Utah salt flats. Which brings me to the concerns being raised about updates to Old Cheney Road east of Highway 2.
Disclaimer: Don't take road-building advice from some guy who blogs from his basement.
There's a literal case of NIMBY going on here so we have to ask ourselves if this is really something Lincolnites as a whole should be concerned with. It is. Roads aren't just about transportation. Roads also help define neighborhoods. For example, compare and contrast Sheridan Boulevard and North Cotner Boulevard. Those two streets communicate very different messages about the neighborhoods they pass through. And need I remind you what the single lane portion of South 27th Street communicates about those neighborhoods? More broadly, those streets communicate oodles about how we, as a community, value the interaction between transportation, home, and business.
One of the concerns expressed by Old Cheney neighbors involves the inclusion of right turn lanes into neighborhoods. The neighbors don't want 'em because it means that much more land has to be taken from their back yards. Road engineers argue that right turn lanes are safer and better promote the flow of traffic. Ditto for medians, which are also optional. So what's our priority? Faster speed limits or streets that don't look like they need an air traffic control tower?
Having traveled the portions of Old Cheney Road that don't feature right turn lanes for most of my life, I'm inclined to say we can feel confident in ditching that feature. The intersection at 35th and Old Cheney, among many others, doesn't feel any less safe because of its lack of right turn lane. Perhaps accident data says otherwise.
As for having a median, I personally prefer well-maintained medians over those bugly center turn lanes as they appear on Pioneers. When there aren't many places to turn into, they use up acres of concrete despite the fact that much of the surface area isn't particularly usable. Ick.
I do have to call out Jon Camp on one error. He argues that Old Cheney's design, as it is currently proposed, is excessive because "this is just a residential arterial". Sorry Mr. Camp, but that's just plain foolish. Sure that portion of Old Cheney isn't much today, but to suggest that it isn't a critical component of Lincoln's long-term transportation plan is bizarrely short-sighted. That's the sort of thinking that has led to some of the transportation problems we have in Lincoln today. Let's not continue down that road (so to speak).